top of page

Water Confidence vs Water Competence

swimcoachkelci
28 sept
8 min de lectura

Actualizado: 14 oct

“They’re so confident in the water.”

 

It’s something I hear from parents all the time. Their child loves the pool, jumps in without hesitation, spends hours playing and seems completely at home in the water. But does that mean they are water competent?

 

This is where I think the difference between water confidence and water competence becomes important.

 

A child can be comfortable in the water while still not having developed the skills to manage themselves effectively in it. Equally, a child can have developed important aquatic skills while still feeling frightened or unsure in the water.

 

Confidence and competence are connected, but they aren't the same thing. Confidence is influenced by how a child feels, what they are familiar with and the experiences they have had. Competence is about what they can do and how effectively they can use those skills when circumstances change.

 

For me, understanding that difference is important when we look at a child's swimming development.

 

What does water confidence mean?

 

There isn’t one single way for a child to look confident in the water. I don’t think confidence has to mean being fearless. For me, water confidence is largely about how a child feels in the water.

 

A confident child may be happy to enter the pool, explore, play, jump in, move around independently and try new things. They may still have preferences, dislike certain sensations and say no to something they do not wish to do in that moment.

 

Confidence can also be very specific to the environment and experiences a child is familiar with.

 

A child might be completely comfortable in the shallow end of their family pool, with their parents nearby, wearing their usual flotation device and doing the things they already know.

 

Change one of those conditions and their confidence can change too.

 

That doesn’t mean their confidence was fake or their parent was trying to make their child sound more advanced than they are. It just means their confidence is influenced by familiarity, environment and experience.

 

When a child loves the water but hates getting their face wet.

 

This is probably one of the easiest examples. A child can adore being in the pool. They might love playing in waist-deep water, jumping in to be caught by a parent, and climbing in and out of the water. But when it gets to the lesson and I encourage them to lie horizontally in the water, get their ears wet, experience water being poured over their face or put their face in the water, suddenly the refusal and dislike can appear.

 

Parents are often surprised by this. “But they love the water!”

 

And they do. There’s no contradiction, they love their experience of the water so far. But playing in the pool is not the same as being comfortable with every sensation and skill involved in learning to swim.

 

Putting your face underwater is a completely different sensation from standing in the shallow end splashing around. Horizontal floating is different from bobbing vertically in floaties with minimal effort. Swimming without touching the bottom is different from walking through waist-deep water. A child can be very confident doing one thing and very unsure doing another.


So rather than simply asking whether a child is confident or not, I think it is much more useful to ask what they are actually confident doing. That tells us much more.


When attached flotation becomes part of a child's confidence in the water.

 

A child spends hours happily in the pool wearing an attached flotation device. From the outside, they can look like incredibly confident and independent little swimmers.


And they may genuinely be confident, but the flotation is providing buoyancy that changes what they can do.


A child may confidently jump into the pool, move around and play without hesitation, but that confidence doesn't necessarily transfer to lessons where there is no flotation and they are learning to manage the water using their own skills.


I've had parents tell me they have taught their child not to get into the pool without their flotation because otherwise they will “drown”. I completely understand the intention. They are trying to keep their child safe. But a child can begin to associate being safe in the water with having their flotation on.


I've heard children arrive at lessons without it and say they will “sink and die” because they haven't got their flotation device. The child who appeared so confident in the pool can suddenly become very unsure when they are asked to do something without the support they are used to.


This is where attached flotation can become part of a child's confidence in the water. The child may be genuinely confident in the environment they know, while the flotation is providing physical support  that makes that confidence possible. Once that support is removed, we may see a very different picture of what the child can actually do and how confident they feel doing it.

 

Confidence isn't the same as competence.

 

Water competence is different. It is about what a person can do to manage themselves safely in the water, and whether they can use those skills effectively when they need them.

 

Depending on the child's age, development and experience, this might include being able to control their breathing, manage submersion, float and recover to the surface for air, orientate themselves in the water, move through the water, tread water, reach safety and exit the water.

 

It is also about what happens when something changes. Can they recover if they lose their position? Can they stop and rest when they need to? Can they respond if they unexpectedly enter the water or find themselves somewhere they didn't intend to be?

 

Being able to perform one swimming skill in a lesson doesn't necessarily tell us how a child will respond when the circumstances change. Competence is not just about what a child can demonstrate when everything goes according to plan. It is about developing a range of skills that allow them to respond to different situations in the water.

 

But what about the child who is competent but has no confidence?

 

This is the other side of the conversation, and one that I think is extremely important.

 

We talk a lot about children who are confident but not yet competent. But what about children who have developed strong aquatic skills without developing confidence?

 

A child can be able to float, travel a distance across a pool, roll onto their backs for air or complete a particular skill and still be frightened of the water. Sometimes, when we see a child performing those skills, we assume everything must be fine. But what if the child has learnt that they must do it? What if they have been put into situations before they were ready and have learnt that crying, resisting or saying no doesn’t change what happens next? What does that teach a child about their own voice and feelings?

 

This matters particularly with young children who may not yet have the language to explain what they are feeling. They might cry, cling, resist, avoid eye contact, become very quiet or simply shut down. If the focus is only on whether the child completed the skill, those signals can easily be missed in the name of drowning prevention.

 

I also hear the argument that young children won’t remember these experiences anyway.

 

It is true that most of us don’t have clear, conscious memories of being a baby or toddler. But not remembering an experience later in life doesn’t mean the experience has no effect on a child at the time. Young children are learning from their experiences long before they can form memories that adults can later recall. So, when a child repeatedly experiences water as something negative they have to endure, rather than something they can gradually explore and understand, I don’t think it is enough to say, “They won’t remember this.”

 

They may not grow up remembering that particular lesson. But they are still having a fearful or negative experience of the water, and that experience matters.

 

This is where I think we need to be careful about confusing compliance with confidence.

 

Are we teaching the skill, or teaching the child to comply?


This is something I think is worth asking ourselves, both as instructors and as parents.

We all want children to learn skills that help keep them safer around water. But it is also worth considering how those skills are being taught, and what the child is experiencing while they learn them.


I’m not suggesting that every child should only do things when they feel like it. Learning to swim involves challenge, and children will sometimes need encouragement to try something unfamiliar or have an off-day.


But there is a difference between supporting a child through a challenge and forcing them through an experience they are distressed by.


Research into child development and learning shows that children do not learn in isolation from their emotional state. When stress becomes intense or prolonged, it can affect attention, self-regulation and learning. Excessive or prolonged activation of the stress response can also affect developing brain systems involved in learning and emotional regulation.

 

Supportive relationships built on trust with caring adults help children regulate those stress responses and provide the security they need to learn and develop. And that does not mean forcing a child through a distressing experience and then excusing it because you gave them a hug afterwards. The relationship matters throughout the experience, not just once the distress has happened.

 

That doesn’t mean there is a right, wrong or one perfect way to teach every child, and it certainly doesn’t mean children should never be challenged. But it does make me question the idea that getting a child to complete a skill at all costs is necessarily the same thing as teaching them effectively.

 

If a child can perform a skill but is frightened, distressed or simply learning to comply, I think we need to look beyond whether the skill was completed. For me, effective swimming development is not about choosing between confidence and competence. It is about helping children develop their aquatic skills without losing their confidence along the way.

 

I want to know more than “Can they do it?” I want to know how they feel while they are doing it, whether they understand what they are doing and why, and whether they are becoming more comfortable and engaged in the water.

 

So what should parents actually look at?

 

Rather than simply asking, “Does my child love the water?”, I think there are much more useful questions to ask.

 

What can my child actually do in the water?

 

Can they comfortably put their face in the water? Can they control their breathing? Can they float or recover to the surface? Can they move through the water without relying on attached flotation? Can they respond if their position in the water changes? Can they cope when something doesn’t go exactly as expected?

 

And just as importantly, how do they feel while doing these things?

 

The aim isn’t to turn every pool visit into a strict swimming lesson. Play, exploration and positive experiences in the water are incredibly valuable. Enjoying the water is important too.

 

Confidence and competence should grow together.


For me, this is really what it comes down to. A child can be confident without being competent. A child can be competent without being confident. And a child can be confident in one situation and completely unsure in another.

 

Confidence and competence should not be something a child has to choose between.

 

A child needs the skills to manage themselves in the water, but they also need to feel comfortable enough to use those skills. They need opportunities to be challenged and to discover what they are capable of, but they also need to feel safe enough to explore, make mistakes and try again.

 

That is why I don't think we should focus only on whether a child can perform a particular skill, or whether they appear confident in the water. I want to see both developing together.

 

As an instructor, I want children to become more capable without becoming more fearful. I want them to gain skills without feeling that the water is something they must endure. And I want their skills and confidence to come from genuine experience and understanding, rather than simply from being made to perform them.

 

Ultimately, I want children to develop a relationship with the water where they feel comfortable exploring it, understand what their bodies can do in it, and have the skills to respond when things don't go exactly as expected.

 

Confidence is how it feels. Competence is what they can do.

Both matter, and I believe the best development happens when they grow together.

 
 
bottom of page